Netanyahu’s appointment of former Navy commander Eli Sharvit as Shin Bet chief collapsed within 24 hours after fierce U.S. criticism and domestic opposition forced a dramatic reversal.
At a Glance
- Netanyahu named former Navy commander Eli Sharvit as new Shin Bet chief to replace ousted Ronen Bar
- U.S. Senator Lindsey Graham called the appointment “beyond problematic” triggering swift American pressure
- Netanyahu withdrew Sharvit’s nomination less than 24 hours after announcing it
- Current Shin Bet chief Ronen Bar remains in position despite cabinet dismissal vote due to High Court injunction
- The controversy stems from Netanyahu’s ongoing investigation known as “Qatargate” involving his associates
Political Shakeup
Netanyahu announced Sharvit as replacement for Ronen Bar, whom the cabinet voted to formally dismiss earlier this month, but the appointment immediately faced intense scrutiny. U.S. Senator Lindsey Graham described the nomination as “beyond problematic”, signaling rare American intervention in Israeli internal security appointments.
The timing proved particularly sensitive given the Shin Bet’s investigation into the prime minister’s associates and their relationship with Qatar, known as “Qatargate”. Critics argued Netanyahu was attempting to install a loyalist who would be more amenable to his political interests.
Netanyahu hoped he had found someone who wouldn’t rock the boat with his choice of former naval commander Sharvit, according to Israeli media analysis. The former Navy chief served as Commander of the Israeli Navy between 2016 and 2021, bringing extensive military experience but limited intelligence background to the role.
Watch a report: Netanyahu’s Security Shakeup Sparks Controversy.
Rapid Reversal
Netanyahu reversed his decision to appoint Sharvit less than 24 hours after the announcement, demonstrating the swift impact of international pressure. The prime minister’s office thanked Sharvit for his willingness to serve while providing no clear explanation for the sudden withdrawal.
With Sharvit out of the running, it remains unclear who Netanyahu may nominate next to lead Shin Bet. The security agency continues operating under Bar’s leadership despite the cabinet dismissal vote, as Bar announced he will end his role on June 15, 2025, to allow for an orderly transition.
The episode highlights Netanyahu’s increasingly difficult position as he attempts to consolidate control over Israel’s security apparatus while managing international relationships and domestic political pressures. The Shin Bet leadership crisis adds another layer of complexity to Israel’s security challenges during ongoing regional tensions.
